01:15
Mark Butcher on England’s issues in the top six
Gary Ballance has been diagnosed with a broken finger which seems certain to keep him out of the team for the third Investec Test against South Africa.
Ballance was struck on the left index finger by a short ball from Morne Morkel on the fourth and final day of the Trent Bridge Test. He went for an X-ray on Monday night and was told the results on Tuesday. He was due to see a specialist surgeon on Tuesday evening with a view to confirming his recovery time and treatment options.
But with the third Test starting on Thursday week, Ballance is unlikely to have time to recover and might struggle in the field, in particular. He has a top score of 34 in the series to date – and an average of 21.25 – and his position was far from secure anyway.
Surrey’s Mark Stoneman is the most likely replacement. Trevor Bayliss, the England coach, admitted after Trent Bridge that Stoneman and Essex’s Tom Westley had been discussed as options ahead of the series and should be considered “on the edge” of the team.
Stoneman, who made half-centuries in both innings of England Lions’ match against South Africa A, could bat anywhere in the top three, providing an opportunity for Keaton Jennings to slip down to No. 3 if required.
His selection will do nothing to appease Durham supporters who feel that ‘more fashionable’ clubs receive more attention from the England selectors. Stoneman, 30, spent a decade at Durham but may well find that, only a few months after moving to Surrey, the selectors’ attention has been grabbed. He is averaging 58.53 in the Championship season with three centuries.
He has been left out of Surrey’s side for the last couple of T20 games and is understood to be training only against a red ball at present.
Bayliss, who admits he has never yet seen Stoneman bat in the flesh, had previously indicated that he was reluctant to consider making too many changes as it be inconsistent with policy of recent months. He might also have hinted, depending on your interpretation of his words, that England’s problems in finding a top-order partner for Alastair Cook may be due to the quality of batsmen being produced by county cricket.
“Since Andrew Strauss, I’ve forgotten how many guys have played at the top of the order,” he said. “All of those guys have been picked because they’ve done well in county cricket.
“They’ve then probably started off well in Test cricket and then fallen away a little. So that’s a concern, obviously.
“But one of the things we’ve tried to do since I’ve come in is give those guys a bit longer to show what they have. It still hasn’t worked, to be honest. But if we’re consistent with our selections Jennings, at the top of the order, should get some more goes.
“The last selection meeting we had before this series started, players like Stoneman and Westley were spoken about at length. Obviously, Haseeb Hameed, too, but he is a little out of form this year. So those guys, they are on the edge.”
England are also expected to provide an update over Mark Wood’s fitness imminently. He suffered bruising on his left heel during the second Test and may be sent for a scan to assess the extent of the damage. Wood has undergone three bouts of surgery on his left ankle.
The squad for the third Test is due to be named on Friday or Saturday.
George Dobell is a senior correspondent at ESPNcricinfo
© ESPN Sports Media Ltd.
Source: ESPN Crickinfo